After I posted my 2019 Reading Year in Review, there were a couple of requests for me to give a ranking of the category romance novels I’d read according to their heat levels. For those who might be unfamiliar with that term, it essentially refers to the sensuality level or raciness of the story. While there are several different explanations for how to rate such things, I’m going to use this one here, which is really interesting and worth reading. (It will also explain with further context the rankings which follow.)
Here are the five levels of heat, in order, with very brief descriptions:
* MILD — Sweet like a Hallmark Christmas movie, and I wouldn’t object to my 9th-grade daughter or 7th-grade son reading them, if they wanted to. (Spoiler alert: Pretty sure she does, pretty sure he does not.)
* MEDIUM — Generally equivalent to a PG-13 movie in that intimate situations or scenes are there, but they aren’t graphically described and won’t likely make people who like the concept of kissing books uncomfortable; I wouldn’t feel awkward recommending books like these to high school students who liked YA romance.
* HOT — Sometimes called steamy, sexy, or spicy, this level includes most category romance books and offers a wide range of description; the titles I’ve included here also represent a wide range within this heat level.
* NUCLEAR — Expect graphic descriptions and possible forays beyond vanilla.
* EROTIC — This heat level pushes boundaries, most definitely; the characters’ emotional journeys are lived through explicit sexual activity, but the emotional journey and the external story still retain primacy — as does the all-important happy story ending.
And here are the titles I read last year, ranked by me:
MILD
Just Add Mistletoe (Moore)
MEDIUM
The Frog Prince (Lothlorien)
HOT
Desire and the Deep Blue Sea (Dade)
Tiny House, Big Love (Dade)
Do You Want to Start a Scandal (Dare)
The Truth About Love and Dukes (Guhrke)
Red, White and Royal Blue (McQuiston)
Rafe (Weatherspoon)
NUCLEAR
Priest: A Love Story (Simone) — And I feel I should make the point here that this novel is not about the horrors we find in the news (though that issue is alluded to regarding characters who don’t appear in the frontstory), but about a consensual affair between adults.
EROTIC
The Professional (Cole)
If you’d like a proper review of any of these titles, just let me know which one(s) in the comments, and I’ll be happy to oblige!
*****
Want to read more of my writing that’s already published? Click here for poetry, click here for urban fantasy, and click here for realistic flash fiction. You can also buy my books in Houston at Blue Willow Bookshop, and I hope you will! 🙂
I’m going to have to go with ‘Carol’ by Patricia Highsmith. Ace storyteller (if a bit weird in herself) and able to make something very simple SEEM erotic.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cool, I’ll check that out. Thanks. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s very woman/woman, but then it would be, coming from me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I knew it would be, coming from you, but I also already knew it about that book. 🙂 It also wouldn’t be my first w/w romance, although I admit I’ve read more m/m titles.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Interesting! I have a friend who writes erotic romance. It’s a bit too far for me. I settle somewhere around medium to hot – just like my salsa preference! Then again, a reviewer described my book as containing “smoldering romance,” and I think of it as decidedly medium. I guess it all depends on who’s doing the judging. 😄
LikeLiked by 1 person
These classifications are definitely a moving target! There were a few titles that I really had to think about before I could classify them on this list, and even so, I’m sure there are readers out there who would classify a few of them differently.
LikeLike
I keep seeing Red, White, and Royal Blue on Great New YA and Great New Queer YA lists. It sounds adorable, and I totally wish there was at the very least a Hallmark movie along these lines. I mean, they do love their royal love stories.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is an absolutely incredible, fun read. Maybe my favorite book of all the ones I read last year? Maybe.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: 2020 Blog Year in Review – Sappho's Torque
Pingback: 2020 Reading Year in Review – Sappho's Torque
Pingback: 2020 Romance Titles Ranked By Heat Level – Sappho's Torque
Pingback: 2021 Romance Titles Ranked By Heat Level – Sappho's Torque