Here’s a cute little song from days gone by. It’s kind of fun to listen to, if you have fond memories of the music of this era.
But there might be more to it.
The premise of the song is fairly straightforward, fairly simple: “You’re an alluring lady, so much so that my attraction to you goes beyond normal, and so there must be something supernatural going on here. But that’s cool, I can roll with that.”
The subtext is also pretty clear: “You’re an alluring lady, and I’m going to enjoy pretending I don’t need to take any responsibility for my actions because of how attracted I am to you.”
I can already hear some of you protesting that I’m making this nonsense up. That I’m ruining something sweet and nice.
Buckle up, buttercup.
You can’t denigrate witches as the ultimate evil predator in league with the devil — a Christian concept if ever there was one — and then also say how lovely and fun and exciting and marvelous and sexy witches are at the same time, unless you do some serious introspection on your particular fantasies and fetishes.
In my English classes we spend a lot of time talking about character agency, or (rather simply) the ability of a character to make decisions and enact choices that have consequences, which in turn have bearing on the plot. (You can read an excellent explanation of character agency in stories here on Chuck Wendig’s blog.)
This song suggests that part of the allure of the “witch” in the song is the usurping of the singer’s agency, “[stripping] [his] conscience bare,” and he’s totally on board. But why?
In the current miasma of what passes for public debate these days, some of the more socially conscious have been talking a lot about personal responsibility.
When I taught AP Gothic Lit., we spent an entire unit of study on the heritage of the Witch as a political figure and literary archetype. Fascinating stuff. For a very small taste of one part of this, check out this wonderful article on the archetype of the “sexy witch” in literature.
One thing that comes up again and again is that — in fairy tales, for example — witches are those characters who are agents of change. Sometimes for nefarious purposes, such as the crone living in a gingerbread hut in the forest or a wickedly vain queen. And sometimes their magics lead to positive outcomes: think fairy godmothers and Glenda the Good.
In the Burning Times, “witches” were more often than not women; and more often than not, defenseless other than through their own fierce and fearless agency; and more often than not, opinionated or otherwise empowered in a way that threatened the patriarchy (in whatever form that might have taken, be it political or religious or social). These days one might imagine a representation of the greatest perceived existential threat to the patriarchy might be depicted as a flash mob of women, having the time of their lives bellydancing in the streets, wearing pointy hats.
Others have written on this subject more eloquently and more coherently than I. Right now, so much of this subject is just swimming around in a maelstrom in my brain. ‘Tis the season and all.
Please, discuss. What do you think of all of this?
7 thoughts on “Witchy Weekends: Frank Sinatra and the Question of Agency”
“You can’t denigrate witches as the ultimate evil predator in league with the devil — a Christian concept if ever there was one — and then also say how lovely and fun and exciting and marvelous and sexy witches are at the same time, unless you do some serious introspection on your particular fantasies and fetishes.”
Oh yes you can. It has been done over and over and over again, and will continue to be done. Why? Because we (humanity) are a race of illogical contrarians. And we deal with that. And sometimes sheer brilliance comes out of it, like that Cy Coleman and Carolyn Leigh song.
And by the way, Frank rocks! 🙂
Okay, fine. It *can* be done. But it’s an indication of a serious character flaw. 😉
Our relationship with the concept of ‘witch’ is long, complex, broad and yet nuanced, and you don’t really need me to tell you that.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s fair. 🙂
Sinatra CDs are on my regular rotation of what I listen to and sing along with when I drive to work in the morning. Singing along with the Chairman of the Board is empowering; it raises my self esteem and leaves me ready to tackle the day.
That’s a kind of witchcraft, wicked witchcraft, too. I enjoy the power of giving into that surge of borrowed confidence from old Blue Eyes. Giving into it is, I know, strictly taboo. But giving in is powerful; giving in is sexy. Proceed with what you’re leading me to.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: Witchy Weekends: Annie Lennox – Sappho's Torque